Primary government expenditures as a proportion of original approved budget (%) - Country Ranking

Definition: Primary government expenditures as a proportion of original approved budget measures the extent to which aggregate budget expenditure outturn reflects the amount originally approved, as defined in government budget documentation and fiscal reports. The coverage is budgetary central government (BCG) and the time period covered is the last three completed fiscal years.

Source: Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability (PEFA). Ministry of Finance (MoF).

See also: Thematic map, Time series comparison

Find indicator:
Rank Country Value Year
1 Uruguay 150.09 2019
2 Libya 137.50 2019
3 The Gambia 131.48 2013
4 Lesotho 131.33 2016
5 Dem. Rep. Congo 129.01 2012
6 Lithuania 127.91 2020
7 Sudan 122.43 2018
7 Tanzania 122.43 2018
9 Slovenia 121.24 2020
10 Finland 119.95 2020
11 Brazil 119.78 2020
12 El Salvador 118.89 2020
13 Madagascar 118.49 2016
14 Russia 117.03 2020
15 Grenada 116.76 2008
16 Latvia 116.70 2020
17 Kazakhstan 116.30 2019
18 Poland 115.91 2020
19 Italy 115.19 2020
20 Romania 114.73 2020
21 Zambia 114.32 2020
22 Ghana 114.15 2020
23 Argentina 114.08 2019
24 Oman 113.22 2019
25 Tajikistan 112.69 2018
26 Uzbekistan 110.17 2019
27 Turkey 109.75 2020
28 Papua New Guinea 109.62 2018
29 Jamaica 107.64 2020
30 Sierra Leone 106.65 2016
31 Cambodia 106.33 2019
32 Solomon Islands 105.53 2011
33 Saudi Arabia 105.46 2020
34 Kuwait 104.65 2020
35 St. Vincent and the Grenadines 104.64 2019
36 Hungary 103.94 2019
37 Serbia 103.61 2019
38 Mozambique 103.30 2014
39 Peru 103.15 2020
40 Montenegro 102.96 2019
41 Belize 102.79 2020
42 Slovak Republic 102.78 2019
43 Panama 102.72 2019
44 Togo 102.61 2015
45 Tuvalu 102.56 2009
46 Morocco 102.42 2018
47 Malaysia 102.38 2018
48 North Macedonia 101.65 2020
49 Nicaragua 101.00 2019
50 Costa Rica 101.00 2019
51 New Caledonia 100.50 2018
52 Lao PDR 100.01 2017
53 Congo 99.87 2018
54 Rwanda 99.80 2017
55 Algeria 99.80 2019
56 Croatia 99.72 2019
57 Greenland 99.67 2012
58 Mexico 99.60 2019
59 Burundi 99.52 2010
60 Afghanistan 99.51 2019
61 Turkmenistan 99.50 2017
62 Ukraine 99.42 2018
63 Norway 99.26 2018
64 South Africa 99.24 2013
65 Ethiopia 98.93 2018
66 Guyana 98.80 2017
67 Switzerland 98.75 2019
68 Nigeria 98.73 2020
69 Chile 98.66 2020
70 Mongolia 98.62 2019
71 Armenia 98.48 2019
72 Georgia 98.46 2019
73 Tunisia 98.42 2020
74 Botswana 98.05 2018
75 Liberia 98.04 2015
76 Myanmar 98.00 2018
77 Somalia 97.67 2018
78 Albania 97.62 2020
79 Jordan 97.49 2019
80 Honduras 97.47 2019
81 Dominican Republic 97.36 2019
82 Côte d'Ivoire 97.35 2016
83 Vietnam 97.35 2017
84 Bhutan 97.26 2018
85 Lebanon 97.07 2019
86 Azerbaijan 96.88 2019
87 Pakistan 96.77 2019
88 Estonia 96.69 2019
89 Senegal 96.49 2017
90 Belarus 95.98 2019
91 Moldova 95.91 2018
92 St. Lucia 95.84 2019
93 Burkina Faso 95.82 2016
94 Kenya 95.59 2016
95 Bangladesh 95.26 2019
96 Chad 95.04 2017
97 Cameroon 94.99 2019
98 Comoros 94.96 2015
99 Thailand 94.93 2019
100 Samoa 94.86 2018
101 India 94.80 2019
102 Seychelles 94.09 2015
103 Suriname 93.99 2017
104 Indonesia 93.87 2019
105 Philippines 93.76 2018
106 Sri Lanka 92.80 2018
107 Mauritius 92.67 2014
108 Mauritania 91.05 2018
109 Uganda 90.20 2019
110 Bulgaria 90.09 2020
111 Antigua and Barbuda 89.15 2012
112 Malawi 88.68 2017
113 Angola 88.53 2018
114 Egypt 88.33 2020
115 Kyrgyz Republic 88.09 2018
116 Colombia 86.76 2018
117 Gabon 86.66 2019
118 Paraguay 86.34 2019
119 Guinea 85.93 2016
120 Ecuador 84.46 2020
121 Iraq 83.93 2019
122 Bolivia 83.88 2019
123 Bosnia and Herzegovina 83.83 2019
124 Haiti 83.76 2020
125 Timor-Leste 83.37 2019
126 Nepal 82.62 2019
127 Cabo Verde 82.55 2016
128 Tonga 81.65 2018
129 Zimbabwe 81.07 2018
130 Mali 79.83 2018
131 Dominica 79.70 2018
132 Benin 78.56 2014
133 Fiji 77.36 2019
134 São Tomé and Principe 73.49 2019
135 Vanuatu 72.00 2018
136 Niger 69.91 2016
137 Guinea-Bissau 69.46 2017
138 Guatemala 66.62 2020
139 Central African Republic 58.47 2009

More rankings: Africa | Asia | Central America & the Caribbean | Europe | Middle East | North America | Oceania | South America | World |

Development Relevance: The indicator attempts to capture the reliability of government budgets: do governments spend what they intend to and do they collect what they set out to collect. The ability to implement the enacted budget is an important factor in government’s ability to deliver public services and achieve development objectives. The deviation between approved and actual spending is measured over a 12-month period (the budget year) and may have important implications for macroeconomic stability, public service delivery, and social welfare. A credibly implemented budget has only small deviations from the approved one. If expenditure is under-executed, beneficiaries may not receive crucial services. Over-executed budgets may result in budget deficits and increased public debt levels and can influence the macroeconomic stability. In both cases, lack of budget credibility undermines the usefulness of the budget process for policy making and implementation and erodes public trust in government.

Periodicity: Annual